Executive summary
Date(s) of inspection:
- April 2023
Aim of inspection
ONR nuclear safeguards inspectors visited the Dounreay site on 25th April 2023 for the purpose of conducting an Accountancy and PITe compliance inspection for material balance area QDR6, D1208 Medium Active Liquor Treatment (Floc) Plant. The intervention will adopt a sampling approach to seek evidence in support of compliance with the Nuclear Safeguards (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (NSR19). ONR will form regulatory judgements and provide a rating in line with ONR’s inspection rating guidance of DSRL’s compliance against the Regulations 6(3), 9(1) and 29(1) in NSR19 and Fundamental SSAC Expectations (FSEs) 6, 7, 8 and 9 as outlined in the ONR Guidance for Nuclear Material Accountancy, Control and Safeguards (ONMACS), Issue 5.Subject(s) of inspection
- FSE 6 Measurement Programme and Control - Rating: Green
- FSE 7 Nuclear Material Tracking - Rating: Green
- FSE 8 Data Processing and Control - Rating: Green
- FSE 9 Material Balance - Rating: Green
Key findings, inspector's opinions and reasons for judgement made
In accordance with the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) Integrated Inspection Strategy (IIS) 2023/24 for Dounreay Division of Magnox Ltd.; hereafter referred to as DSRL, ONR Safeguards conducts Safeguards compliance inspections at the DSRL site. This intervention was performed to inspect DSRL’s compliance with the requirements of the Nuclear Safeguards (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (NSR19) in relation to operation of the Physical Inventory Take (PIT). For this intervention, the Material Balance Area (MBA) known as QDR6 (D1208 (Medium Active Liquor Treatment (FLOC Plant) was selected, and the inspection planned as a Physical Inventory Take Evaluation (PITe) focused compliance inspection.
This inspection sought to collect evidence of arrangements and their implementation to make judgements of compliance against NSR19 Regulations 6 (3), 9 (1), and 29 (1).
I conducted an accountancy and PITe compliance inspection, focussing on the MBA QDR6 at the DSRL nuclear licensed site. The inspection comprised of discussions with staff, review of measurement procedures, demonstration of accountancy systems, operation of physical inventory takes, and reviews of associated procedures, operating and accounting records.
The inspection targeted two areas: The operator’s procedures for performing a PIT and producing the associated accountancy reports; including the measurements underpinning these reports and the Accountancy and Tracking of Materials (ATOM) nuclear material accountancy system. This involved a demonstration of the ATOM system and review of traceability from operator records to the associated accountancy reports.
This intervention was performed in line with ONR's guidance (as described in the relevant technical inspection and assessment guides, which can be found on ONR’s website (onr.org.uk).
I identified two minor shortfalls as part of the inspection as follows;
- A minor shortfall in the implementation of adequate quality assurance for the material balance report (MBR) in accordance with NSR19 Schedule 2 6(3). This resulted in an error in the submitted report requiring a minor correction. A minor regulatory issue has now been raised for DSRL to investigate the cause of this error and propose a solution to prevent it from re-occurring.
- A minor shortfall against NSR19 9(1). Non-compliance with an internal procedure requiring the production of a form for the general areas of D1208; as described within the Accountancy and Control Plan (ACP). Although the check was conducted in accordance with the procedure. The associated form was not produced as no material was present. I raised this as regulatory advice that this form should be updated to reflect a zero value, Progress against this will be tracked at ongoing level 4 meetings.
- A measurement program as described within the ACP.
- A system to track qualifying nuclear material and retained waste within D1208.
- A data-processing system as claimed within the ACP.
- A system to document and produce accountancy reports.
Conclusion
Based on the sample inspected, I judge that DSRL are implementing their arrangements for the operation of a PIT in line with their ACP and that the implementation of these arrangements is supporting the accountancy and control of QNM in-line with regulatory expectations and are compliant with the following NSR19 requirements:- Regulation 6 – Accountancy and control of qualifying nuclear material
- Regulation 9 – Operation of Accountancy and Control Plan
- Regulation 29 – Stock list and accounting records for conditioned and retained waste
- Regulatory shortfall: I identified a minor shortfall in the implementation of adequate quality assurance for the material balance report (MBR) in accordance with NSR19 Schedule 2 6(3). This resulted in an error in the submitted report requiring a minor correction. A regulatory issue has now been raised (RI-11412) for DSRL to investigate the cause of this error and propose a solution to prevent it from re-occurring.
- Regulatory shortfall: A minor shortfall against NSR19 9(1). Non-compliance with procedure D1208/SI/ACC/01 requiring the production of form D1208/FORM/SI/ACC/01(03) for the general areas of D1208; as described within the Accountancy and Control Plan (ACP). Although the check was conducted in accordance with the procedure. The associated form was not produced as no material was present. I raised this as regulatory advice that this form may be updated to reflect a zero value, Progress against this will be tracked at ongoing level 4 meetings.